Picture: FG Trade/Getty Photographs

It was difficult to predict pattern strains for the payer and health and fitness insurance policy market in 2021, mostly since of persistent uncertainties because of to the COVID-19 pandemic. Shopper actions has turn into more unpredictable, care versions and offerings are shifting and payers are adapting to a planet which is evolving quickly and in unpredicted ways.

1 aspect that has been rendered incredibly unpredictable by the virus is the financial health and fitness of the nation’s key insurers, which soared for the duration of the initial waves of the pandemic in 2020 but then settled back down to earth toward the conclude of that year. In 2021, insurers still posted typically sizeable revenue, but they were significantly from the heights observed the prior year.

More than the course of the year a couple of basic themes began to emerge. Insurers are plowing forward with digital transformation initiatives, including the enlargement of telehealth and virtual health and fitness. Synthetic intelligence and equipment studying have labored their way into the blend and 50 % of payers now have innovation labs in the belief that digital innovation will be the important to the long term.

Insurers also continued to consolidate in 2021, ensuing in hugely concentrated markets that have drawn the focus of the federal federal government, which seeks to curb consolidation in a bid to empower people.

And then there is certainly Medicare Benefit, which proceeds to increase it truly is estimated MA ideas will deal with more folks in 2022 than unique Medicare. Many key insurers have taken see, growing their MA offerings in an effort to capture more of the industry.

It can be been a wildly distinct year in the payer place, but the way it has performed out implies several of these pattern strains may keep on into 2022 … and beyond.


COVID-19 proceeds to have an effect on every single facet of American existence and the healthcare market, and it truly is driving trends in the payer planet as very well. At the HIMSS State of Healthcare occasion in June, Shreesh Tiwari, principal at ZS, stated the coronavirus has led to an enhance in payer adoption of engineering and innovation.

Sixty-four % of health and fitness insurance policy executives report an accelerated adoption of digital health and fitness initiatives this sort of as virtual health and fitness. Another 53% report an acceleration in adoption of synthetic intelligence and equipment studying practices, while forty two% stated COVID-19 has assisted facilitate the adoption of benefit-centered care preparations, according to State of Healthcare exploration by HIMSS, the mother or father firm of Healthcare Finance Information.

COVID-19 has assisted to push alterations not just in engineering, but in mind-set, Tiwari stated. The mental and cultural boundaries in conditions of adoption are no for a longer period staying observed as difficulties.

Close to 50 % of payers have an innovation lab and imagine AI and equipment studying will push innovation forward. But 53% imagine healthcare startups will direct the way in driving huge engineering innovation, Tiwari stated.

The federal government also plays a important purpose. Forty-six % of payers feel present guidelines and polices will facilitate innovation.

“Payers have tasted the fruits of innovation in the earlier couple of months,” Tiwari stated at the time. “Interoperability is staying observed as a important driver in conditions of managing difficulties coming out of the engineering infrastructure, details infrastructure difficulties we have, intently followed by details privacy and details stability.”

Not all of insurers’ digital initiatives are going flawlessly, however. Well being ideas are revamping their digital offerings in a bid to make sure you people, but these initiatives are intricate, a Deloitte study located in June. Several ideas are battling to properly prioritize assignments, suggesting a absence of obvious eyesight.

In simple fact, about 50 % of the 35 engineering leaders surveyed recognized this absence of eyesight as an impediment to these ongoing digital transformation initiatives. 

Buyers are the ones mostly afflicted, as customer-facing platforms have produced the least progress. A small about 50 % of respondents, fifty seven%, stated they are still in the procedure of advancing these courses, while the remainder haven’t still began but say they are going to do so in the subsequent two several years.

There are other regions that are lagging as very well. The study concentrated on modernization initiatives of 5 engineering platforms – administrative, analytics, scientific, core, buyer assistance and engagement – and only two respondents stated they had modernized a person of those platforms.

Individuals surveyed recognized cyber and information and facts stability as the amount two financial commitment precedence just after business enterprise intelligence. But they warned it could be expensive to suitable cyber-similar issues, specifically ones getting to do with cloud configuration. Baking in cybersecurity in DevOps from the outset could make for a more productive and resilient procedure.

The conclusions discuss to the broader problem of affected individual engagement, which has been an ongoing challenge for health and fitness ideas and insurers. A J.D. Power 2020 U.S. Professional Member Well being Approach study located that 60% of privately insured U.S. health and fitness plan customers stated they had not been contacted by their health and fitness plan with guidance or information and facts similar to COVID-19, and nearly 50 % (forty eight%) stated their health and fitness plan has not shown concern for their health and fitness considering that the pandemic started.

Well being ideas have not received buyer centricity, as just 36% of commercial health and fitness plan customers stated their health and fitness plan acts in their very best curiosity “always” or “most of the time,” and just twenty five% stated they perspective their health and fitness plan as a reliable spouse in their health and fitness and wellness.

This absence of buyer-centric positioning resulted in an general gratification rating last year for commercial health and fitness ideas of 719 on a one,000-point scale, amid the lowest of all industries evaluated, according to J.D. Power.

THE Increase OF MEDICARE Benefit

Medicare Benefit enrollment continued to enhance and several key insurers expanded their MA footprints. It can be turn into a warm industry for insurers heading into the new year.

The Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Products and services stated that in 2022, MA is projected to reach 29.five million folks as opposed to 26.9 million enrolled in a Medicare Benefit plan in 2021. 

For several seniors, MA is the favored health and fitness insurance policy since of its minimal upfront month-to-month prices and additional rewards. Medicare Benefit ideas will keep on to give a wide selection of supplemental rewards in 2022, including eyewear, listening to aids, both of those preventive and thorough dental rewards, entry to foods (for a limited duration), about-the-counter items, health and fitness rewards and all over the world crisis/urgent coverage. 

In addition, the proportion of ideas presenting special supplemental rewards for chronically unwell persons will enhance from 19% to twenty five%.

An rising amount of Medicare Benefit twin qualified special wants ideas deal with both of those Medicare and Medicaid companies for folks who are dually qualified. In 2022, 295 ideas (as opposed to 256 in 2021), will deal with all Medicare companies, additionally Medicaid-lined behavioral health and fitness cure or lengthy-term companies.

CMS will keep on to test the Part D Senior Price savings Design for insulin for seniors in more than 2,a hundred ideas in 2022. This year, about 500 new Medicare Benefit and Part D prescription drug ideas, as very well as two new pharmaceutical manufacturers of insulin, are joining the model that cuts down out-of-pocket paying.

Also, more than one,000 Medicare Benefit ideas will take part in the CMS Innovation Center’s Medicare Benefit Worth-Primarily based Coverage Style Design in 2022, which assessments the influence of presenting a projected three.7 million folks customized rewards built to much better manage their conditions and address social wants from foods insecurity to social isolation. 

The VBID Model’s Hospice Gain Ingredient, now in its second year, will also be offered by 115 Medicare Benefit ideas in parts of 22 states and U.S. territories. It offers enrollees elevated entry to palliative and integrated hospice care. 

To aid with their Medicare prices, minimal-cash flow seniors and adults with disabilities may qualify to get financial assistance from the Medicare Price savings Programs. Only about 50 % of qualified folks are enrolled, CMS stated.

Cigna is finding on on the act by growing its MA ideas, expanding into 108 new counties and 3 new states – Connecticut, Oregon and Washington – which will enhance its geographic existence by nearly thirty%, the insurance provider stated in October.

As element of the enlargement, Cigna stated most present customers will pay back the same or reduce rates, and promised that every single industry will have at least a person $ premium plan. Other rewards will include a social connection system to overcome loneliness, customized ideas for folks with diabetic issues and incentives for yearly wellness exams and other preventive care.

Cigna has elevated its geographic existence in MA by eighty% considering that 2019, the insurance provider stated. The firm now provides ideas in 477 counties throughout 26 states and the District of Columbia.

Centene, in the meantime, stated this year it will be broadening its reach in the Medicare Benefit place in 2022, growing into 327 new counties and 3 new states: Massachusetts, Nebraska and Oklahoma.

In all, this represents a 26% enlargement of Centene’s MA footprint, with the presenting readily available to a possible forty eight million beneficiaries throughout 36 states. Presently, Centene serves more than one.one million MA customers throughout 33 states.

In September, Centene also announced it would consolidate its present Medicare manufacturers, including Allwell, Well being Internet, Fidelis Care, Trillium Benefit, ‘Ohana Well being Approach and TexanPlus, below a person unified brand dubbed Wellcare.

In the meantime, UnitedHealthcare, which presently has considerable industry command with its Medicare Benefit ideas, will fortify its foothold in the place by growing its MA ideas in 2022, adding a possible three.one million customers and reaching 94% of Medicare-qualified people in the U.S.

Presently, more than 7.three million folks are presently enrolled in UnitedHealthcare’s Medicare Benefit ideas. The insurance provider stated the enlargement will concentrate on decreasing prescription drug prices, and bettering rewards and the member experience.

But while UnitedHealthcare has a huge foothold in the Medicare Benefit place, it underwent scrutiny from the federal federal government previously this thirty day period, when the Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Products and services blocked four Medicare Benefit ideas from enrolling new customers in 2022 since they failed to spend the minimum amount threshold on professional medical rewards. 3 UnitedHealthcare ideas and a person Anthem plan unsuccessful to hit the needed 85% mark 3 several years in a row.

Medicare Benefit ideas are needed to spend a minimum amount of 85% of premium dollars on professional medical fees failure to do so for 3 consecutive several years triggers the sanctions.

For UHC, the penalties apply to its MA ideas in Arkansas, New Mexico and the Midwest, which encompasses Missouri, Kansas, Nebraska and Iowa. UHC ideas deal with about 83,000 customers, and the Anthem plan covers about one,200 customers. They cannot give decide on ideas to customers until eventually 2023, assuming they hit the 85% threshold subsequent year – what is called the professional medical reduction ratio (MLR). If they fail to hit the threshold for 5 several years in a row, the federal government will terminate the contracts.

UHC reps explained to Bloomberg that it missed the 85% benchmark in specific markets in element since of patients deferring professional medical care because of to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Humana also announced it would debut a new Medicare Benefit PPO plan in 37 rural counties in North Carolina in reaction to industry desire in the japanese element of the point out. 


Well being insurance provider consolidation has been one more ongoing pattern – and a person the present administration would like to see with tighter reigns.

An govt buy issued by President Joe Biden in July cracked down on healthcare facility and health and fitness insurance policy consolidations and other steps it stated decreases opposition and drives up selling prices. The four regions of healthcare specific are: prescription medicine, healthcare facility consolidation, health and fitness insurance policy consolidations and listening to aids.

Consolidation in the health and fitness insurance policy market has intended that several people have small alternative when it arrives to selecting insurers, the buy stated. 

Biden directed the Office of Well being and Human Products and services to standardize plan alternatives in the health and fitness insurance policy marketplace so folks can comparison store more very easily. Designs offered on the exchanges are intricate by the numerous companies offered and variances in deductibles, the buy stated.

Rick Pollack, president and CEO of the American Healthcare facility Association, urged federal organizations at the time to concentrate on guidelines that address opposition amid commercial health and fitness insurers.

“In simple fact, with commercial health and fitness insurance policy ideas, nearly 3 out of four markets were hugely concentrated in 2019 and the top 5 most significant insurers on your own command nearly 50% of the industry. Reports have located that when an insurance policy industry is hugely concentrated, insurers lower supplier payments and do not pass discounts together to the customer.”

The outcomes of consolidation in 2021 also prolonged to prescription medicine. Consolidation amid standalone Medicare Part D prescription drug ideas was the root cause of a 23% drop in offerings for 2022, according to conclusions printed last thirty day period by the Kaiser Spouse and children Foundation.

The common Medicare beneficiary will have a alternative of 23 stand-on your own prescription drug ideas (PDPs) in 2022, seven fewer PDP alternatives than in 2021, the details showed. Despite the fact that the amount of PDP alternatives in 2022 is significantly reduce than the peak in 2007 – when there were fifty six this sort of alternatives, on common – there are still quite a few standalone drug plan alternatives, according to KFF.

The rather significant decrease in the amount of PDPs for 2022 is mostly the consequence of consolidations of plan offerings sponsored by Cigna and Centene, ensuing in the industry exit of 3 national PDPs from just about every organization in just about every area: all 3 of Cigna’s Convey Scripts PDPs and 3 of Centene’s six Wellcare PDPs. Part D sponsors are limited to presenting no more than 3 PDPs in just about every area. 

This accounts for just about 200 PDPs offered in 2021 that will no for a longer period be offered in 2022. Enrollees in these consolidated ideas will be quickly switched to other ideas offered by the same plan sponsor, whilst they can pick to swap into a distinct plan for the duration of the yearly open up enrollment time period.

The amount of firms sponsoring stand-on your own drug ideas has declined steadily about time, from more than forty firms in 2010 and previously several years, dropping below twenty five firms commencing in 2015, and at 16 firms in 2022. That’s reduce than in any other year considering that Part D began. 

PDP enrollment is envisioned to be concentrated in a small amount of firms in 2022, as it has been every single year. Primarily based on August 2021 enrollment, eight out of 10 enrollees in 2022 are projected to be in PDPs operated by just four firms: CVS Well being, Centene, UnitedHealth and Humana. All four firms give PDPs in all 34 locations subsequent year.

Irrespective of these year-to-year alterations in plan coverage and prices, as very well as alterations in beneficiaries’ health and fitness wants, a prior KFF examination located that most Medicare beneficiaries did not evaluate ideas for the duration of a modern open up enrollment time period, and most Part D enrollees did not evaluate the coverage offered by their drug plan to other drug ideas.

The quantities are comparable throughout both of those Medicare Benefit and standard Medicare, with 68% of MA beneficiaries saying they do not evaluate professional medical ideas, and seventy three% of those in standard Medicare boasting the same.

Twitter: @JELagasse
E-mail the author: [email protected]